Skip to content
Business Automation

The Evening CMA: Cut Prep Without Cutting Accuracy

Lionmaker SystemsNovember 5, 20268 min read

8:40 PM, the night before the appointment

The appointment is at 10 AM. The agent got home at 7, ate, and sat down at the kitchen table at 8:40 to pull comps.

First the obvious ones: three sales on the same street in the last six months. Then the harder part. One of them had a finished basement. One sold to a cash buyer in nine days. One has a two-car garage and the subject has a carport. The agent is now doing arithmetic in her head on condition, and typing notes into a spreadsheet she rebuilt from a template someone sent her in 2021.

At 10:15 PM she exports it, drops it into the brokerage's presentation file, fixes the logo that moved, and goes to bed. The appointment goes fine. It usually does. That is not the issue.

The issue is that this happened for every listing appointment in your office last week, and it will happen again this week, and the hour it takes is an hour nobody bills for and nobody sees.

What the hour is actually made of

If you break the evening CMA apart, most of it is not judgment. It is retrieval and formatting.

Pulling the sold set is retrieval. Pulling tax records, lot size, beds and baths, days on market, list-to-sale ratio: retrieval. Checking whether the neighborhood has moved since those sales closed: retrieval, from numbers that already exist. Laying it out in your brokerage's format with your cover page and your market summary: formatting.

The judgment is narrower than it feels. It is which comps actually belong in the set. It is what the kitchen is worth in this neighborhood versus that one. It is what you say about the asking price given what the seller told you on the phone about why they are moving. That part is the agent, and it should stay the agent.

So the goal is not a faster agent. The goal is for the agent to arrive at a drafted CMA and spend her time on the twenty minutes that require her, instead of the forty that require a keyboard.

Step one: settle the format before you speed anything up

You cannot shorten a process that is different in every agent's hands. Before anything else, decide what a CMA from your brokerage looks like.

Pick one existing CMA from your office that you would be proud to have a seller read. Not the fanciest one. The clearest one. Then write down what it contains, in order: cover, subject property summary, comparable sales with photos, adjustments, active and pending competition, absorption or months of supply for the area, a suggested range, a net sheet if you use one, and the agent's marketing plan.

Write down the rules too. How many sold comps minimum. How far back you go. How wide the radius goes in your tightest neighborhoods and your rural edges. When a pending counts. How you handle a subject with no true comp. These are decisions your best agents already make the same way; you are just writing them down.

That document is worth more than any speed trick. It is the thing that lets prep be handed off at all, whether to a person or to anything else.

Step two: build the set before the appointment is booked

Most of the retrieval does not depend on seeing the house. It depends on the address.

The moment a listing appointment is set, you know the subject address, the approximate size, and the neighborhood. That is enough to pull the sold set, the active competition, and the market summary. None of that needs the agent to walk the property first.

So move that work forward. The standing rule becomes: when an appointment goes on the calendar, the comp set and the market numbers get assembled that day, not the night before. The agent then walks the house, adjusts for condition, and the number is close to finished when she gets back in the car.

This single change takes the evening CMA from an hour to roughly twenty minutes, before you automate a thing. It also kills the worst version of this problem, which is the appointment booked Tuesday for Wednesday morning where there is no evening to use.

Step three: standard adjustments instead of fresh math

Ask three of your agents what a finished basement is worth in your main neighborhood and you will get three answers. Each one defensible. Each one arrived at from scratch, in the evening, by someone tired.

You can set this once. Sit with your two or three strongest listing agents for ninety minutes and build an adjustment sheet for your core areas: garage bay, finished square foot below grade, updated kitchen, updated baths, lot premium, waterfront or view where it applies, age bands. Note the basis for each, and note the areas where it does not apply.

The sheet is not the final word. The agent can override any line and say why. But the agent starts from a number your brokerage stands behind instead of inventing one at 9 PM.

There is a second benefit, and it shows up in listing appointments. When a seller pushes on an adjustment, the agent can say this is how our brokerage prices that feature across this market, and show the basis. That is a different conversation than "I weighed it."

A quick note before the next part

If you want to see what the hours spent on CMA prep add up to across your roster in a year, the Leak Report lays out the arithmetic for each of the six leaks at systems.lionmaker.io/apply. Takes a few minutes to read.

Step four: hand the first draft off entirely

Once the format is written down, the adjustments are set, and the retrieval is moved forward, the first draft stops being a creative act. It becomes an assembly job that follows your rules.

That is where the second leak closes. We call it the number before the visit: the gap between the seller wanting a figure and your brokerage being ready to give one. Atlas drafts the CMA in your brokerage's format, using your comp rules and your adjustment sheet, and sends it to the agent. The agent opens a finished document, changes what her eyes caught in the house, approves it, and sends it.

Nothing goes to a seller without an agent saying yes. You decide that. A brokerage can start with every draft routed for approval and keep it that way as long as it is useful.

What the agent's evening looks like after that: she reads a draft on her phone at 8:40, flags that comp three had an original kitchen and the subject does not, adjusts, approves. Done before 9.

What the faster number does at the kitchen table

Speed here is not about the agent's comfort. It is about what the seller experiences.

Sellers who call you are usually calling two brokerages. The one that gets a real number in front of them first is the one that frames the conversation. Everyone after that is arguing with an anchor somebody else set.

There is also the seller who texts the night before and asks what we think it is worth. Today the honest answer is often "I'll bring a full analysis Thursday." That answer is professional and it is also a week of silence in a moment when the seller is deciding who to trust. When a drafted range exists that morning, the agent can send something real and still bring the full presentation Thursday.

And when a seller asks what the commission actually pays for, a CMA that arrived fast, backed by named sales and a stated method, is a specific answer instead of a general one.

What to do this week

Three things, in order, none of which require you to buy anything.

First, pick your model CMA and write down the rules behind it. One page. Comp count, lookback window, radius rules, how pendings count. Send it to the office as how we price a home here.

Second, change when the work starts. New standing rule: the comp set and market summary get pulled the day the appointment is booked, not the night before it. Say it at the sales meeting and watch one week of appointments to see if it held.

Third, build the adjustment sheet with your two strongest listing agents. Core neighborhoods only to begin with. Expand it when it earns the right.

Do those three and the evening CMA shrinks on its own. Then the question of handing the first draft off entirely becomes an easy one, because you have already written down what a good draft looks like.

The part worth protecting

None of this is about taking pricing away from your agents. Pricing is the thing they are paid for and the thing a seller remembers. It should stay with the person who stood in the house.

What is worth moving is everything around it. The retrieval, the formatting, the logo that drifts, the spreadsheet rebuilt from a template nobody owns. That is the part your agents are doing at a kitchen table at 9 PM, and it is the part that does not need them.

Lionmaker Systems builds each of these inside your own phones, your CRM and your files, with your rules and your voice, and the first leak is live in about two weeks. You decide what sends on its own and what waits for an agent's approval.

If you want to walk through where your brokerage leaks and what the second one costs you in a year, book the 15-minute Private Automation Briefing at systems.lionmaker.io/apply, or read the Leak Report there first. Our team replies within 24 hours.

Back to The Playbook