Skip to content
Business Automation

The Past Client Who Listed With Someone Else

Lionmaker SystemsNovember 11, 20268 min read

You find out from the MLS

It is a Tuesday morning and you are scrolling new listings in your own town. There it is. The colonial on Harbor Street. You sold it four years ago. Your agent sat at that kitchen table for two hours talking them through the inspection.

The listing agent is someone else. Nobody poached anything. No one called, and someone else did.

You already know what happened. Your agent liked those clients. Meant to check in. Had a closing that week, then a listing, then a buyer who needed three weekends. Four years went by in the way four years do.

The names are already in your files

A brokerage with ten agents and a few years of history is sitting on hundreds of past clients. Every one of them knows your name, has been inside your process and has no reason to shop around if someone they trust is still in their life.

That is the part that stings. This is not a lead cost problem. You already paid for these relationships. You paid in showings, in negotiation, in the Saturday the deal almost fell apart and your agent fixed it.

The leak is not interest. The leak is contact. The work of staying in touch is small, repetitive and never urgent, and anything small, repetitive and never urgent loses to whatever is on fire today.

Why follow up loses every single week

Follow up has no deadline. A showing has a time. A contract has a date. A past client check in has nothing forcing it, so it moves, and then it moves again.

It also has no owner. The agent assumes it is their relationship to tend. The brokerage assumes the agent is tending it. Nobody is wrong, and nobody is doing it.

And it feels awkward to do badly. An agent who has not spoken to someone in three years does not want to open with a sales question. So the message gets drafted in their head and never typed. The gap keeps getting wider, which makes the next attempt harder.

This is the listing week leak showing up in its slowest form. Sellers left waiting is the obvious version. Past clients left waiting is the same leak on a four year delay.

What a working follow up system has in it

Start with the list. Pull every closing your brokerage has done in the last five years into one place: name, property address, close date, agent of record, phone, email. One row per household. If that list lives in three spreadsheets and your CRM, merge it this week. That is the single highest value hour available to you right now.

Then decide the touches. Not a campaign. A short, fixed set of moments where contacting someone makes obvious sense. Our suggestion, and you can cut it down:

The closing anniversary, every year. A market note on their street twice a year, naming actual nearby sales. A property tax assessment note when assessments go out in your county. A hello in the first week of the year. A check in when a home within a few blocks of theirs closes above what they paid.

That is roughly six contacts a year. Enough to be present, not enough to be noise. The anniversary is the one that does the heavy lifting, because it is the one date that is about them.

Make every message say something true

A follow up message that only says "thinking of you, let me know if you ever want to sell" teaches people to ignore you. A message that carries information gets read and sometimes gets answered.

The anniversary message should say what the home is likely worth now and what nearby homes sold for in the last year. Specific street names. Specific numbers. Signed by the agent who sold them the house, not by the brokerage.

The market note should be about their four or five closest comparable sales, not the county. Nobody cares about the county. Everyone cares about the house two doors down.

And the voice matters. These messages go out in the agent's name, in the agent's way of writing. A past client should read it and hear the person who sat at their kitchen table.

Build it once, then stop deciding

Here is how to put it in place this week without buying anything new.

One. Export your closings. Clean the list. Assign each household to the agent who closed it, and to a second agent for any name whose original agent has left.

Two. Write the six messages as templates, once, as a brokerage. Leave blanks for the address, the comps and the number. Keep them to four or five sentences. Agents can adjust the wording for their own voice, and most will adjust two lines and keep the rest.

Three. Put the anniversary dates on a calendar that is not an individual agent's calendar. A shared view where you can see next month's anniversaries in one screen.

Four. Pick one morning a week. Friday works for a lot of offices. Someone pulls the week's anniversaries, fills in the comps, drops the drafts in front of the right agent, and the agent sends. Fifteen minutes an agent, not an hour.

The discipline is in step four. Everything else is setup you do once. If the Friday block holds, the system holds.

If you want to see what this one leak costs a brokerage your size before you build anything, the Leak Report at systems.lionmaker.io/apply puts a number on it.

A number you can run on your own roster

Here is an illustration, not a claim about anyone's results. Use your own figures and see what you get.

Say a 25-agent brokerage has closed 900 sides over the last six years. Say half of those are sellers and owners you could plausibly serve again, so call it 450 households in your territory. Say one in twelve of them transacts in a given year. That is about 37 transactions moving through your past client base annually.

Now put your own average commission against that. If you are present with those people, you compete for all 37. If nobody has spoken to them since closing, you compete for the few who happen to remember your name when they need it.

You do not need to win all 37. Winning six more than you won last year, at your average side, is a number worth protecting a Friday morning for. Run the math on your own list before you decide how much this matters.

What the Friday morning looks like when it runs itself

The manual version works. It also depends on a person remembering, every Friday, forever, through closings and vacations and the week everything goes sideways. That is why it usually lasts about four months.

The version that lasts does the pulling and drafting without anyone remembering. The anniversaries come up on their own. The nearby sales are pulled. The message is written in the agent's voice, with the actual address and the actual comps, and it lands in front of the agent ready to send. The agent reads it, changes a word, sends it. Or you decide after a few months that the anniversary note goes on its own and the agent only sees replies.

That is the work Shepherd does. He keeps past clients hearing from their agent on time, and every message he sends is tagged "Automated by Lionmaker AI" so nobody is pretending otherwise. He works inside your CRM, your phones and your own closing files, with your templates and each agent's voice.

You and your agents decide what sends on its own. Plenty of brokerages start by approving every message for the first month, then loosen it once they have read fifty of them and like what they say.

What it changes beyond the listings

Agents who stay in touch stop feeling like they are starting from zero every January. They have a book. The book produces calls. The calls produce listings they did not pay a portal for.

The seller side gets easier too. When a past client does call, your agent is not reintroducing themselves. They are continuing a conversation. That changes the kitchen table conversation about the fee, because the service the seller is paying for started years before the listing.

And you stop finding out from the MLS. That is worth something on its own.

The first leak at a brokerage goes live in about two weeks, built inside the systems you already run, set up with your rules and your voice. Lionmaker Systems builds one Digital Employee per leak, so you are not changing how the office works, just closing the place it leaks.

If you want to walk through where your own brokerage leaks, book the 15-minute Private Automation Briefing at systems.lionmaker.io/apply. The Leak Report on the same page will show you what each leak costs in a year, and you are welcome to take that number and fix it yourself.

Back to The Playbook